Young Adults – The Missing Generation?

by Annika Mathews, former Church of England Youth Council member and rep on General Synod

Hi there, young adult Anglican speaking. Who’s that you ask? It’s me, but not just me, as there’s quite a number of us actually if you look more closely! We may seem like a ‘missing generation’ in the Church, but we do exist (including on ‘Anglican Twitter’). You’ll find several of us in the big resource churches or town centre churches which offer not just activities but also pastoral care tailored to us and our needs. Some smaller churches have some young adults too, but many lack 18-35 year olds. The national Vision and Strategy project quite rightly prioritises under-18s and their voices are starting to be heard; see the recent press release on this work given to the House of Bishops) But I believe that the 18-35 age range are just as important to engage, not least as emerging leaders in Church and society with much to contribute in action and word. Some of us will have recently come to faith and need adequate opportunities for discipleship and fellowship.

At diocesan level, the picture is mixed. Some dioceses have very good provision for young people, including youth councils; for example, Worcester.  Vocationally, things are better. The ministry experience scheme runs for 18-30s and a few new monastic communities, such as the Tree of Life in Leicester, have been a success.

Nationally, the situation is bleaker. The Church of England lags behind other denominations. Alongside their national engagement with young people, the Catholics have many religious communities holding events for young adults. The United Reformed Church, Orthodox and Pentecostal churches all organise national events for young people. The Methodists have a team engaging with young adults and asking their opinions on aspects of church life, including at their Conference. They run a popular annual event, 3Generate, for young people as well as supporting events like Cliff Fest.

Yet the C of E used to have a Youth Council (CEYC). Known as its ‘best kept secret’, it was shut down a few years ago, though its memory lives on in this webpage. You can read more about that in the excellent article by Ed Cox here. CEYC had some good support (mostly by Mary Hawes, National Children and Youth Adviser and a few others in the Education Department), but was not allowed to advertise its events through main church comms and the allocated budget was limited.

As a result, its reach was regrettably small, although like others I benefitted hugely from my time on it. I only found it by chance after seeing an advert for General Synod observers and duly being selected. I then ended up standing as a Youth Rep and joining the core team. Both being on Synod and attending the CEYC residentials helped broaden my knowledge of the diversity within the Church of England and enabled me to worship with and learn from those within completely different traditions to those I was used to. Most importantly, it gave me other young adults to worship with and connect to, as my ‘home’ church at the time had hardly any.

Although it was never enabled to reach its full potential, the Youth Council occupied an important space in and outside the Church. I gained in leadership and speaking skills and my first months on the Youth Council solidified my desire to be confirmed. Others who attended found or fulfilled their vocational calling in a multitude of directions; some are now clergy. It gave young people a voice at General Synod through elected reps and also had a connection to some other denominations through event exchanges as well as a space on the British Youth Council. Most importantly, the events were run for young people by young people in a peer-for-peer model. With its demise, no national engagement with young people currently takes place.

A new conference model similar to the Methodists’ provision for young people was briefly proposed but Covid and the restructuring of the NCIs ended that. When the youth reps left at the end of the quinquennium, there was a clear change in the responses given at Synod to questions about provision for young people in Synod representation and beyond. Compare the response to Question 1 from a Synod session in November 2020 (Q1) and those given to Questions 42 and 43 in February 2022. While a few young adults have been elected by dioceses, there are no youth reps anymore on Synod. Yet the Spirit is stirring. The Anglican Communion have just launched the Young Adult Theology project. A small group of young adult Anglicans in the UK meet, network and worship together occasionally online. There is a long running (though invite-only) group for Young Priest Theologians.

The 2030 Vision and Strategy process includes the decision to ‘grow younger and more diverse’ so there is still some hope that the missing generation will not be forgotten but will be properly included in Church of England structures and decision making, not only as a tokenistic add-on or as staged representatives in church campaigns or staged photo opportunities, as sometimes feels the case (my photo was used to promote the Synod election campaign). Though there has been some great work done by those in the Education Department collating written responses from teenagers at schools on their hopes for the Church, and a few young people joined a fringe group to present their ideas at the February 2022 Synod, it is time to take things up a level and provide more opportunities for young people to interact with the rest of the Church at different levels of its structures (following appropriate safeguarding measures of course). The restructuring of the NCIs meant the loss of two jobs directly connected to young people: will there now be action by the national Church, as well by dioceses and parishes, to engage with young adults? We need to support ideas financially from a marketing and comms perspective to successfully reach the right people. One good place to start is through the National Church connecting more with chaplaincies at universities and colleges.

National initiatives to engage young adults could include coordinating regional days for Anglicans from different church traditions to come together for fellowship and worship; organising or at least facilitating a pilgrimage or trip to a holy site, either in the UK or abroad – to a retreat house, Taizé or the Holy Land; a presence at Christian festivals like Greenbelt; and more observer and participatory opportunities for young adults on national Church bodies. In particular we need an accessible online space to advertise opportunities for young adult Anglicans; for example, chances to apply to be part of Churches Together Forum, or to steward at World Council of Churches events. I was fortunate to have these opportunities through becoming known on General Synod, but it shouldn’t only be ‘who you know’ which opens doors to these oportunities. We need inclusion, not exclusion. Including all young people (across a whole diversity of identities, a true representation of the body of Christ) is of paramount importance.

Young people need to be seen as a priority now, valued for their gifts and personalities as well as the prophetic voice they bring to the Church. It will be too late when the Church realises that a dearth of under-35s now will spell a dent in the coffers of parish funds in 20 years’ time.

Young adult Anglicans exist, and we are watching. We are already joining in with what’s happening on the ground and are keen to partner with the rest of the Church in broadening its reach to more millennials and Gen Z and amplifying their voices and participation in the Church. SOS. Church, listen and respond with urgency now!

 

 

 

Comments

13 responses to “Young Adults – The Missing Generation?”

  1. Vee Pinto avatar
    Vee Pinto

    Powerful words! Thank you x

  2. Natasha avatar

    Great article. Very informative. Thank you.

  3. Susannah Clark avatar
    Susannah Clark

    Excellent article. Thank you.

  4. Froghole avatar
    Froghole

    Many thanks for your efforts. For the last 15 or so years I have been undertaking a pilgrimage around the country, which has led me to attend services at about a third of the national stock. If anything, the situation is far more urgent and desperate than you describe. I can easily attend services at 100 or so churches and barely see anyone below pensionable age. Whilst there might, on occasion be a few families, young adults and adolescents are conspicuous in their absence everywhere bar a few suburban evangelical churches, and one or two churches in some university towns.

    The leadership of the Church needs the most almighty kicking to get it to appreciate just how dire things are. It too often seems to me that they prioritise the hoarding of assets and/or the diversion of capital from the parishes all the better to secure their own pay and pensions. The Commissioners have lately announced that they will more or less double their subventions to their favoured projects (for which bids will need to be made – bids which struggling churches will too often lack the resources or wherewithal to submit). These subventions will not come even close to addressing the scale of the problem, which is how to capture even a small segment of the cohort that is between about 11 and 21 (i.e., when peoples lifetime habits and outlook are mostly formed). The complacency of the Church towards this cohort over my lifetime has been remarkable (and remarkably foolish). I would suggest that at least a fifth of the Commissioners’ resources be directed to mission for this cohort. Naturally, much of that capital will be wasted and will not result in much success, but some success may make all the difference between modest survival and the extinction towards which we are presently definitely headed.

    In addition, the burden of the parish share has to be alleviated. It was utterly imbecilic to pass the full weight of stipends (1995) and pension accruals (1997-98) from the Commissioners to the parishes at a point at which the parishes needed to increase significantly their investments in youth work to offset the radical, and negative, impact which the liberalisation of Sunday trading (1994) had on weekend timetables. Parish share has crowded out investment in youth work, and most mission work. I assume that the parishes have had to bear the almost full burden of ministry costs since 1998 on the basis that the Commissioners might be able to provide substantive help (after overreach in the 1970s and 1980s) once they had built up a large enough buffer fund. Well, now they have (though it is imperilled by rising economic headwinds), only the Church has rapidly died off in the interim. A decade ago, the then first commissioner, Whittam Smith, declared that the Commissioners needed to increase investment in mission or else the Church would end up as a large pension fund with no attendees. Well, that prediction is rapidly coming to pass, and the investments that have been made (in ‘Lady Bountiful’ fashion) do not come even close to what is required if any form of survival is to be assured.

    You also mention to paltry representation of young people in the counsels of the Church. I think that should tell you all you need to know about the priorities of those in authority: effectively boomers catering for other boomers, a pattern depressingly characteristic of the country at large.

    Many thanks again.

    1. Susannah Clark avatar
      Susannah Clark

      That is a coherent and (to me) persuasive line of analysis, Froghole.

      Might I ask, if anyone here can answer, how many people under 30 are elected members of General Synod? How many people under 25?

      If, as I fear, the figures are very small percentages of the total Synod, could it be argued that there is a kind of reverse ageism going on here? I appreciate that with age comes its own insights and experience, but how is ‘voice’ of young adults heard at General Synod (except by proxies), and how are young adults empowered in the governance of the Church of England?

      You and I, Froghole, are probably boomers ourselves (I may be doing you a disservice) but I really hope we both press for less top-down, ‘Grandpa/Grandma knows best’ mentality in the Church. On the basis of your stats, they don’t.

      As a starter, I think their needs to be platform for ‘voice’ for young adults – a publicly accessible ‘voice’ – with a commitment of Church leaders to respond to questions, and engage in unfolding dialogue. The right of one young adult from every Anglican church and community in the country to have membership of a forum would be one approach, I suppose.

      But that’s not for this boomer to decide. The decisions about young adult ‘voice’ should be taken by young adults themselves.

      1. Helen King avatar
        Helen King

        I think there are 5 or 6 under 30, Susannah, but I may be able to find the accurate figure…

      2. Helen King avatar
        Helen King

        Apparently, by the end of 2022 there will be 13 members of synod who are aged 30 or under, 12 laity and 1 clergy. Four will be under 25, the youngest 22 this year.

      3. Froghole avatar
        Froghole

        Susannah and Prof. King: Many thanks. I am, I suppose, Gen. X (18 Dec. 1975), and I feel as though I am part of a generation that has been overwhelmingly lost to the Church. Would I ever have gone to church to interact with my own generation? Certainly not, because almost none of them were to be found there. As far as the Church is concerned, I am part of a demographic desert, and what I have found especially depressing on my tours has been not only the paucity of people born after c. 1950 (though really more like 1940), but: (i) the lazy assumption, which I hear time and again, especially from clergy, that old people will be replaced by new cohorts of old people (though there’s now scant evidence of that, in my view); and (ii) the staggering complacency of the Church, which views young people as a ‘problem’ to be confronted, as if they are almost alien.

        I agree that Church policy towards young people needs a radical shake-up, but what it needs more than anything else is money. Very serious money. At present the authorities are not being serious. They may think they are, disbursing a few million here, and a few million there, but they are not being remotely serious compared to the scale of the problem. That is only one of the reasons why I have long since concluded that it is really, far, far too late, and that what we ought to concentrate on is saving the buildings for public benefit, and hope there will somehow be a sea change in public attitudes, although the changes are that there won’t be.

        As to Synod (a body about which I have emphatic views), the total membership is presently 467. There are presently 21 MPs aged under 29. Being a Synod member is not remotely comparable to being a professional politician. That the youth membership of Synod is so dismally small, even compared to the House of Commons (another body about which I have very strong views) pretty much says it all.

        Ms Matthews’ article has been linked to Thinking Anglicans. What are the chances that some other news story will attract much more attention that Ms Matthews’ plea, the subject matter of which is incontestably, and vastly, more important than anything else, because it is about the basic survival of the Church? The Church cannot promote justice, or even continue being unjust as it is towards certain groups, if it has ceased to exist.

      4. Susannah Clark avatar
        Susannah Clark

        Thank you very much, Helen. By my calculation, if 16 to 24 year olds (ie under 25) young adults were to have proportionate representation in the House of Laity in general Synod, (discounting under 16s) then there should be about 32 members under 25 speaking for their age group, not 4.

        If the Church of England is a National Church, should not 16-24 year olds have a voice proportionate to the national population of that age group?

        We should hear young adults, and they should be embedded in our governance structures.

        They have so much to offer, as I know, having worked with teens for over 25 years.

      5. A Mathews avatar
        A Mathews

        Thanks for your contributions to this important topic. I hope once restructuring is complete at the NCIs, that the Church will provide this forum nationally for young adults to have a voice at.

    2. A Mathews avatar
      A Mathews

      Thanks – have you raised this via General Synod reps or written to the official Church people involved? You make lots of salient points. Thanks for highlighting them and adding to the discussion.

  5. Bob avatar
    Bob

    An interesting article. Some ways in which the church I belong to has been seeking to attract those in their 20’s and 30’s are to encourage them to be on PCC, to encourage them to be involved in welcoming people on a Sunday, involving them in leading music and worship, having a specific person to head up 20’s and 30’s ministry and setting up specific 20’s and 30’s small groups for bible study and social activities. As a result the number of 20’s and 30’s attending has increased considerably.

    1. A Mathews avatar
      A Mathews

      Yes, inviting people to serve definitely helps but there needs to be a better action by churches in including and supporting young adults too pastorally. My church has just started something specifically for young adults and though numbers are sometimes small, they are consistent and it has been helpful for creating community. Just expecting young adults who sometimes have different needs to older people to fit into structures which are there already is one of the issues I’ve found.

Any thoughts?