The Actual Value of Women

Written by

in

by Chantal Noppen, a Team Vicar in North Wearside and a member of General Synod. She describes herself as a feisty, direct, urban priest with a heart for justice

Last week at General Synod was interesting, affirming, frustrating and confusing, probably in equal parts. It’s a steep learning curve but I’m gradually starting to feel a little less at sea. I even found myself making not one, but two speeches on topics close to my heart, which I hope landed in the ears of those who most need to hear them!

As I listened to the debate on how we fund and support those in training for ministry, whether it is for ordained or lay work, I found myself musing on my own experience and discovered I still have some residual anger and frustration about it. Things don’t change fast in the church, but change is needed. Before I knew it, I was on my feet requesting to speak…

Here’s part of my story.

I left home at 18. I am an only child, but I was pretty self-reliant financially and I juggled working alongside my undergraduate studies. I became the proud owner of a little Tyneside flat in Newcastle. By the time I’d got over the mountain of self-doubt and applied and then been accepted to train for ordination, I’d lived in my flat for six years. I’m not exactly cut out to live alone, nor was that a financial practicality, so I’d always had lodgers and I planned to rent the flat in its entirety while I was training, to cover the mortgage. I considered selling up but was reluctant to do that, as getting on the housing ladder is not something to throw away lightly.

When I suggested that I should defer my training for a year to concentrate on saving up some funds to give me a buffer while I was away, the diocese assured me that this wouldn’t be necessary, and that they would support me if I were to lose my tenants. Then of course there would be the holidays and I could work in those, like many students do. It would all be fine: I shouldn’t worry.

Of course, a few months in, I did lose my tenants and my diocese was unable to offer me financial assistance – the offer had of course only been a verbal one.

So I applied for grants, many grants, for which I was mostly unsuccessful: too catholic for the evangelical ones, too female for the Catholic ones. Yet around me I could see male ordinands without my financial responsibilities being awarded grants to spend on books… or whatever they fancied really. It was not a comfortable reality.

I was told that Oxbridge students are meant to agree not to take on jobs during term-time as their studies should, and would, demand their full attention. I then discovered that the church would also be claiming all my holiday time that first year, sending me on placements. So, no temping either. The Bible might encourage us not to be concerned about tomorrow, but the fear of the inevitability tomorrow will bring does somewhat overshadow today, especially if financial worries are at its root.

It was through the grace of God, sheer stubbornness and a very generous friend that I managed, but it is not a time I look back on fondly.

I share my story because not all ordinands are the same. We can’t assume that everyone has parental financial support, a well-earning spouse or savings squirrelled away. We can’t assume that none of them has financial responsibilities. If we want to become more diverse and genuinely open to those from more working class, self-sufficient backgrounds, this needs addressing.

Alongside this, let’s also name the elephant in the room, and that is the pressure on women to be self-supporting, or simply to magic childcare out of thin air. If a woman is the breadwinner in their family, heading to training will have an immense impact on family finances.

The Church of England need to be bolder and think bigger. Let’s stop just scratching the surface on how we assess the training, formation and growth we support and offer, and let’s stop kidding ourselves that one size can fit all. Let’s actually listen to the statistics and questions raised by groups such as WATCH. Listen to the stories and experiences of those from less stable middle-class backgrounds on the barriers to training. Why do we push people into self-supporting ministry or non-residential training; is it because it actually suits their skill-set and circumstances, or is it simply easier for the Church?

Let’s ask, and listen, to the hard truths around why younger women aren’t coming forward. It’s not rocket science. What maternity support is actually in place; in reality, not just aspirationally? Young women ordinands will become young curates, with their biological clocks ticking down. Women need to know where they stand, and where they will stand, if they choose to have a family. Childcare is expensive, but surely we are past assuming that women will, and should, prioritise providing it themselves if they are called to something else?

Be bold, invest and be transparent. Let’s not offer support we cannot provide but let’s really consider the options. No-one should have to experience the level of pressure, isolation and worry I did during training; handling the dismantling of my self and painful introspective navel-gazing was more than enough without that!

Women, both lay and ordained, are worth investing in. We are, after all, literally a source of growth and potential. Please don’t underestimate, undervalue or ignore us.

 

 

 

 

Comments

3 responses to “The Actual Value of Women”

  1. Graham Holmes avatar
    Graham Holmes

    Ordinands misled, lied to, and given inaccurate advice, but none of it in writing or accountable or attributable? Now there’s a surprise! Would that happen during their active ministry, or approaching or during retirement? (Rhetorical questions of course)

  2. Peter avatar
    Peter

    The diocese was entirely wrong to mis lead you with the suggestion they would support you if you lost your tenants. However, keeping your place on the housing ladder was surely your decision. A perfectly sensible decision but not one that should have any bearing on your ordination training support

  3. Janet avatar
    Janet

    I very much related to this! When I trained, in my late 20’s, I had no home of my own and not much in the way of savings. I was extremely grateful that fees were paid covering tuition and food. Problem was what to do in the vacations around placements. I was a nurse so I applied for temporary work at the local hospital where they basically said, ‘If we’re helping you out by giving you a part time job, you will help us out by working when & where we want you to.’ So two years out of three I actually spent more weeks working in A&E and ICU (where there was a lot of responsibility) than I spent at college. I felt completely caught between 2 worlds – the NHS wasn’t interested in anything other than how many hours I could work and the college treated my ‘holiday job’ as though I was doing a bit of light work in a cafe that could be cancelled at any moment. Luckily the hospital was near a copyright library so I could do a day’s work in the library, a shift at the hospital and just about fit in a few hours sleep. I got the impression college might have asked more questions had anyone had the faintest idea what an ICU nurse does on an 11 hour shift. I don’t remember any sense of reality from the diocese: basically they didn’t want you to work too much as they thought it would affect your ‘formation’ but they didn’t offer any suggestions about how to survive financially. In fact it set me up well to cope with the variety and demands of parish life but not, I think, in the way the ordination training intended.

Any thoughts?