The Sexism Women Continue to Face in the Church of England


by Rev Martine Oborne, Chair of WATCH (Women and the Church), a group that works for gender equality in the Church of England

At Christmas parties this year, the chances are that someone will start talking to you about the dire national census results for the Church of England, which show that less than 50% of people in the UK now identify as Christians. If, like me, you are ‘in the Church’ in some capacity – perhaps a minister or a Churchwarden – they’ll want your take on it. Why don’t people go to Church anymore? How can people sit down to turkey and all the trimmings without first spending an hour in a chilly ancient building singing ‘O Come all ye faithful’?

These are good questions. And there are many possible answers. On the positive side, perhaps our Christian values have become so embedded in our culture that we no longer need to be stirred up from the pulpit. Or, on the negative side, perhaps we are put off by a Church that can’t seem to make up its mind about gay marriage. Quite often, however, there’ll be one person at the party who starts going on about the female vicar of their local village church and how everything has gone downhill since she arrived.

So I want to give a big shout out for that female vicar, and all the other female vicars and leaders in our Church. Do you have any idea how hard they work, how often they feel unvalued and what they have to put up with?

Usually, the said female vicar has made some kind of change which is, of course, what all new vicars do. Maybe she has asked the Choir to occasionally sing a hymn that was written less than a hundred years ago. Maybe she has introduced an all-age service on the first Sunday of the month – for the two or three children who hardly ever come. She might even have succeeded in growing a congregation of families who now annoy ‘the regulars’ because they don’t sit still and make too much noise. The reason she is doing these things, of course, is a desperate attempt to build a wider congregation than the handful of septuagenarians and octogenarians she has inherited. A male vicar who did this would also be annoying to the indigenous congregation, but a female vicar gets it in the neck because she is a woman. Somehow, it’s simply because she is a woman that she is doing these things. Which is, of course, pure sexism – or unconscious bias, at the very least.

But sexism is still sadly par for the course in the Church of England. In 2014, with great fanfare, women were finally allowed to be bishops as well as priests. But, in almost complete silence, provisions were then made so that parishes who didn’t accept female vicars and bishops could avoid their ministry. And this situation remains.

So our vicar, who simply happens to be a woman, just has to put up with this. If she was ordained since 2014 she will have had to sign on the dotted line to say that she accepts that the Church both recognises her as a priest, but also recognises that some, including her colleagues and maybe even her bishop, don’t recognise she is a priest – and that is how the Church intends things to be indefinitely. This means that there may be a church in the next village where she could not cover a Sunday service because that church’s bishop isn’t confident she can consecrate the sacraments validly. And there may be a church in the nearby town, where she could not lead a service because that parish believes that women should not preach to mixed congregations.

Our woman vicar will be working six days a week, sometimes looking after about six or seven churches and often not being paid a penny. More women are ordained later in life than men and they tend to get directed towards leading small churches or groups of small churches – often without a salary. Men tend to get ordained earlier and end up in paid posts leading bigger churches in more urban environments. One clergy colleague once explained to me why this made sense by saying, ‘Men are generally more dynamic than women and should therefore lead the bigger churches.’ Again, pure sexism.

Earlier this month, Rev Rob Munro was appointed Bishop of Ebbsfleet to provide episcopal ministry to churches who do not accept female vicars and female bishops, although this purpose was cloaked in church jargon so that any ordinary person might have struggled to understand. The Church said that Munro ‘will have a special national ministry to parishes of a complementarian evangelical theology across England… [who] are unable to receive the priestly or episcopal ministry of women,’ which is fairly clear. But Munro, in his interview with The Church Times, simply talked about his ministry being for ‘resolution churches.’ Neither explained what complementarian theology is – the understanding that God created men to lead and women to submit in the Church and in marriage. Even the word ‘complementarian,’ which is now being used to replace what was previously referred to as ‘male headship,’ is misleading because it suggests equal balance and fairness, rather than one sex having authority and control over the other.

Of course, neither I nor most of my colleagues in the Church of England agree with this theology but we feel under great pressure not to debate the matter, certainly not publicly. As Chair of Women and the Church (WATCH), a national campaign group for gender equality in the Church, I want to help us lift the lid on the ongoing sexism and discrimination that women, both ordained and lay, experience in the Church and help to change the culture. One of the things that we are asking for is that every church should have a statement in clear English about any limits it puts on women’s ministry in a logical and visible place on its website. This way, ordinary churchgoers can easily be aware of this matter. Munro says he doesn’t believe this should be required – he says it’s up to churches to say whatever they think is important on their websites. But, despite claiming that their theology on women’s ministry is so important they need a special bishop to look after them, churches who limit women’s ministry are mostly saying nothing on their websites or saying something in incomprehensible language on a page deeply buried within it.

This isn’t about naming and shaming, it’s about being honest on a matter that ordinary Anglicans care about deeply. We have all worked hard to bring discrimination to an end in the secular world but, thanks to exemptions that the Church has under The Equality Act 2010, it can go on discriminating legally. Many people want to be members of churches who say no to this and feel angry when they find out, sometimes after years of support including financial donations, that their church limits women’s ministry. Furthermore, it’s not just a theological matter – these beliefs result in practices that impact women’s opportunities in the Church and their well-being.

The Student Christian Movement recently launched a campaign called #honestchurch seeking churches to be clear on their websites regarding their theology about LGBTQ+ people. Their CEO, Naomi Nixon, was featured last week on Via Media. And we join with SCM in seeking equal clarity about women.

So, when you go to Church this Christmas, and I hope you will, please spare a thought for your hardworking vicar. And, if that vicar is female, please tell her she’s doing a great job, a job she has every right to do. If you are ‘in the Church,’ please make sure you know where your Church stands on all this and who your bishop is and what their position is. Not to be a nuisance, but for the long-term good of our Church.

After all I can’t believe that, if we brought an end to discrimination in the Church of England, this would not have something of an impact on those dire statistics.

Comments

12 responses to “The Sexism Women Continue to Face in the Church of England”

  1. Anne Peat avatar
    Anne Peat

    As you say, churches just need to be honest about how their leaders feel about women in ministry. So often, it is only them who have these discriminatory beliefs but the whole church community is limited by it.

  2. Catherine Bush avatar
    Catherine Bush

    Fabulous article! Churches must be clear about their stance on women’s ministry and the concept of complementarianism simply cloaks a horrible sexism and bias against women! Shall we just lead the Sunday School and arrange the flowers…??

  3. Cheryl Collins avatar
    Cheryl Collins

    In my last post before retirement, having been a priest since 1994, I was told that ‘Of course, we would have preferred a male priest, but we really like you…’and ‘because you took that funeral so well, someone in this congregation who had a problem with female priests has changed their mind.’ Please someone, pat me on the head!

    I am aware that such experiences are not unusual for my female colleagues. It is not just the ‘theologically motivated’ opposition that we face, but the casual everyday sexism of our church and our society. A place where it’s OK to express appalling views about a woman in the public eye (Jeremy Clarkson, I’m talking about you) in a national newspaper; and to claim that ‘everyone of my age shares that view’. A place where, along with other groups perceived as ‘different’ or ‘lesser’, it is ‘normal’ for women to be denigrated, abused and for at least one woman each week to be subjected to violence that kills them. It might seem a bit dramatic to link everyday sexism to extreme violence and abuse. I’ve recently re-done my Safeguarding training to obtain PTO and was asked to comment on how watching such things as the Peter Ball documentary had affected me and my view of safeguarding. I said that while the documented abuse and institutional indifference and cruelty shown in that documentary and in other works like ‘Bleeding for Jesus’ was in no way comparable to the everyday denigration I and hundreds of other priests who are women have suffered, we needed to recognise that it is a continuum. We cannot have a safer church for anyone until we admit to, repent of and allow God to transform our attitudes, words and actions which promote a culture of bullying, dishonesty and cronyism into those which attempt to demonstrate what living in the kingdom of God looks like.

  4. Barbara Andrew avatar
    Barbara Andrew

    Their position should be also among the notices pinned in the church porch, a source of “hidden” information!!

  5. Graham Watts avatar
    Graham Watts

    Don’t worry. Just remember what Justin said in 2017. Plenty of honesty here!
    “No person is a problem, or an issue. People are made in the image of God. All of us, without exception, are loved and called in Christ. There are no ‘problems’, there are simply people.
    How we deal with the real and profound disagreement – put so passionately and so clearly by many at the Church of England’s General Synod debate on marriage and same-sex relationships today – is the challenge we face as people who all belong to Christ.
    To deal with that disagreement, to find ways forward, we need a radical new Christian inclusion in the Church. This must be founded in scripture, in reason, in tradition, in theology; it must be based on good, healthy, flourishing relationships, and in a proper 21st century understanding of being human and of being sexual.
    We need to work together – not just the bishops but the whole Church, not excluding anyone – to move forward with confidence.
    The vote today is not the end of the story, nor was it intended to be. As bishops we will think again and go on thinking, and we will seek to do better. We could hardly fail to do so in the light of what was said this afternoon.
    The way forward needs to be about love, joy and celebration of our humanity; of our creation in the image of God, of our belonging to Christ – all of us, without exception, without exclusion.”
    (Yes I am being sarcastic!)

  6. Peter avatar
    Peter

    If people have a principled conviction that women’s ministry should include ordination and episcopal preferment that must be respected.

    However it is disingenuous to claim that churches must make this or that statement about their “position” on certain issues because it is dishonest to do otherwise. The intention is obviously to compel congregations to accept a particular set of convictions as to what is of first importance.

    A congregation is perfectly entitled to make their own minds up as to what they say on their notice boards.

  7. Marian Birch avatar
    Marian Birch

    Another aspect of such conservative evangelical sexism is the assumption that the wife of their clergyman (and most conservative evangelical parishes are not keen on unmarried clergyman – and clergywomen are of course beyond the pale!) will be a ‘helpmeet’ to their husband in the parish. This often extends to quasi-interviewing wives (a practice which is probably technically illegal but which still happens). It also extends to expressing disapproval if the wife makes it clear that her own career and vocation is important to her. The problem is also that such practices end up not simply applying to those couples who might be willing (or even happy) to go along with them – but somehow legitimate attempts to treat non-evangelical couples in the same way. I speak from bitter experience as someone that parishes thought they had the ‘right’ to interview when my husband applied for various positions a number of years ago – and who, when I made it clear that I was not prepared to go along with this, withdrew offers of interviews made to my husband. I also speak from the experience of trying to explain my anger and frustration about this to a bishop (conservative evangelical) whom I can only describe as truly evil – only to have my husband told by this appalling man that due to my views he would not allow my husband to apply for further positions in the diocese of which this wicked and abusive person was then a suffragan bishop. Although such attitudes and incidents are not precisely the concern of WATCH I do feel that they are in reality the other side of the coin to the misogyny faced by many women clergy.

    1. martineoborne avatar

      What a shocking and depressing story, but thank you for sharing. I don’t suppose you are willing to say who this abusive bishop was?

      1. Marian Birch avatar
        Marian Birch

        He knows who he is. I have written to him personally. I had what I would call a grudging apology, though I don’t really think he understood how deeply I considered his behaviour to be abusive and demonic. (I am sure it was linked to his ‘headship’ views.) I would prefer not to say publically who he is, although I have shared his name with a number of other key figures in the C of E in my attempts to get such practices (quasi-interviewing) as I experienced outlawed. I think in the C of E as a whole they happen much less these days – but it does concern me that I think they are still tolerated even now in the conservative evangelical segment of our Church. And I don’t think they should be. All the agreements that have been made to pacify that part of the Church e.g. in 2014 related to women clergy – there was nothing ever spelled out in relation to the roles of wives of male clergy. Perhaps I would also like to say that neither my husband nor myself allowed our appalling experience with that evil man ultimately to define our future paths, either in our work or in our marriage; we both later had fulfilling careers in which we were well appreciated, and the way we had been treated eventually knitted us closer together as a couple. But this issue of ‘wives’ still does require a bit of watchfulness. When the C of E church (not ConEvo – indeed a long way from that) of which I am a member of the PCC was advertising a couple of years ago for a new priest, other PCC members wanted to invite ‘spouses’ to accompany candidates to the interviews so that they could ‘see’ the church and meet the people. Sounds superficially good; but in reality it can turn into an informal interview with the spouse. And even if it doesn’t, it discriminates against spouses (like myself) who have the kind of job in which it is not easy to take a couple of days off to accompany our husband to an interview for a position that he might, or might not, get. I think that I was probably in a minority of one on the PCC on this topic – but COVID intervened, and the interviews eventually happened on line.

  8. Simon avatar
    Simon

    I have a particular perspective on this issue arising from an experience I had a few years ago. I arrived in a new post, inheriting a situation in which the published rota of services included the name of the person presiding at the Eucharist. I discontinued this practice on the grounds that it embedded a subtle but real discrimination against the sacramental ministry of women for reasons I regarded as obvious. The consequences were not happy. A formal complaint was made to the Independent Reviewer and I became embroiled in a very public controversy. It was a salutary experience. To my intense sadness it was also very isolating because of the lack of any substantial support received from clergy, either male or female. I would do the same again, but am cynical about the likelihood of any clergy, men or women, entering the lists in support.

    1. Peter avatar
      Peter

      Simon, Have you considered the possibility your action was ill judged ?

    2. martineoborne avatar

      Thank you for trying with this.

Any thoughts?