The Invisible Privilege of Being Voiceless in the Church: Creating a Platform for Bisexual Christians

by Hattie McInerney, a second-year Theology and Religion PhD researcher at the University of Birmingham

In 2019, when writing my Master’s thesis, I decided to interview 10 university students who identified as Christian and LGBQ+. Personal and thought-provoking, these interviews gave me a real insight into how queer Christians navigated their faith lives, both in their home churches, and on their university campuses.

During my research I discovered Carol Shepherd’s work Bisexuality and the Western Christian Church: the first time I’d read an academic, theological piece that focused purely on bisexuality. It led me to reflect on my own personal experiences, as a Christian with faltering faith, and someone who had been questioning their sexuality for a long time. I was keen to know more. Diving further into the bisexual Christian field, I was surprised to see only a small handful of names turning up. Why wasn’t there more research in this area? Why were bisexual Christian voices smothered so deeply under the experiences of lesbian and gay Christians? Why did some texts, proud to reference bisexuality on their covers, then fail to mention it even once within their work?

These questions, alongside the fantastic interviews I’d hosted with some bisexual participants, spurred me on when identifying a topic for my PhD. I decided to explore every nook and cranny of Church of England attitudes, policy and paperwork: what exactly did the Church have to say about bisexuals?

It was then that I was introduced to Issues in Human Sexuality.

Don’t get me wrong, I was aware of Issues beforehand, but I certainly couldn’t say I’d read it cover to cover. Looking further into the text led me to discover Section 5.8, a neat paragraph of 119 words arguing bisexuality’s ambiguity, labelling bisexuals as ‘inevitably unfaithful’, capable of redemption only through heterosexual marriage or by seeking some form of professional help. At the November 2021 General Synod, it was vehemently stated that this passage does not encourage conversion therapy, but the call for bisexuals to ‘seek their truth’ and to gain ‘inner healing’ through counselling says otherwise.

The Church’s most recent sexuality publication, Living in Love and Faith, was released in November 2020. The 400+ page document takes an awful lot of tree to say very little at all, and if anything demonstrates the lack of clarity surrounding what today’s Church actually thinks of human sexuality. Has the Church really progressed? 31 years since the release of Issues, ordinands are still expected to assent to a document that calls those in the bisexual community confused, frisky individuals needing help.

As I continued to examine policy, I began to think back to my MA interviews, alongside my own personal experiences. I only returned to church in September 2021, and one month prior to this, I became happily engaged to my male partner. When considering my positionality in this project, I began to face a roadblock. Many methodologies in qualitative research argue a strong ‘insider’ or ‘outsider’ position for their researchers, but where did I fit in? Male-only relationships throughout my life, a slightly broken relationship with the Church after leaving the ordination process during my MA; how could I call myself a Christian, when sometimes I felt God and I were constantly on different paths to one another? How could I call myself bisexual, when despite the gender of my attractions not mattering to me, I only ever seemed to end up in ‘straight’ relationships? I consistently found myself floating in the grey space between inside and outside, unsure of exactly where I’d fall.

For my PhD, I have so far spoken to ten participants; six identifying as bisexual and Christian, and four who worked on Living in Love and Faith. These interviews reveal the disparities between those who are involved in policy and documentation processes within the Church, and those who experience what it’s like to live as bisexual Christians; and let me tell you, their experiences are far from those promiscuous and ambiguous lives depicted in Issues. Whilst not wanting to give away all my research, one key point from a bisexual Christian has really stood out: that bisexuals experience a truly invisible privilege in the Church.

Comments

5 responses to “The Invisible Privilege of Being Voiceless in the Church: Creating a Platform for Bisexual Christians”

  1. kathleenjowitt avatar

    Oh, I’m really interested to hear more about this!

    1. Hattie McInerney avatar
      Hattie McInerney

      Hi Kathleen, I’m so sorry to have only just seen your comment! Would be delighted to share more.

  2. Carol Shepherd avatar

    Yes, I was disappointed just how little Living in L&F had to actually say, and yet again, bisexuality pretty much off the table for discussion, despite accounting for over 50% of LGBT+ folk. Carol Shepherd

  3. Philip Melia avatar
    Philip Melia

    Hi Hattie, I am finding material by Carol Shepherd really interesting and helpful, particularly her book ‘Bi The Way’. I am wondering when your own research work might be available for wider public reading…a book planned maybe?
    I am a bisexual male returning to faith after a 30 year absence from church circles and am endeavouring to find my own position on Christianity and LGBT matters.

    1. Hattie Heath (was McInerney!) avatar
      Hattie Heath (was McInerney!)

      Hi Philip, Carol’s material is definitely fantastic, she’s done some great – and very important/needed work! I’m aiming to have finished my thesis by early Summer 2024… not sure what the plan is yet r.e. books/publications etc, but I will make sure to return here and let you know… 🙂

Any thoughts?