Thirty Years On

by Rev Martine Oborne, recently appointed Chair of WATCH (Women and the Church), a group that works for gender equality in the Church of England

Thirty years ago, in 1992, I was appointed to the main board of an investment bank in the City called Rothschilds. I was 34 and the youngest woman to have been made a Director in the firm.

At the same time, a battle was being fought in the Church of England to dismantle the legislation that blocked women from becoming priests. I was almost unaware of this at the time because I had largely given up going to church and would barely have called myself a Christian. Nonetheless, as I look back on 1992 today, I think how I might have been in the thick of that battle if I had stuck firm to the calling I had first received as a child – that God wanted me to be a vicar in his church.

I didn’t come from a churchgoing family, but my parents sent me and my sister to Sunday School to get us out of the house so that they could have ‘a bit of time to themselves’ (whatever that meant!). And I became a very spiritual child, praying, reading my Bible, enjoying being in Church, watching my vicar Father Stephen and feeling that one day I might grow up and do the things he did. Lighting candles, reading from scripture, talking about God and chatting to old ladies.

One day at school when I was about ten, my teacher started asking the class what we wanted to be when we grew up. One kid said an astronaut, another said Prime Minister, another said a film star and so on. But, when it got to me, I blurted out that I wanted to be a vicar. This was greeted with much laughter from my friends.  And then my teacher said, ‘Well, you can’t do that, Martine – they don’t have women vicars.’ And, at that, the whole class collapsed into fits of mirth while I just sat there feeling an idiot.

I felt not only stupid but also confused.  It was the late 1960s and brave women were battling to breakdown discrimination in all areas of the public sphere.  And they were succeeding.  So why was it that I could not be a vicar, just because I had been born female?

I began to wonder what my calling might be.  In my mid teens I had a time of worrying that I might be called to be a second Virgin Mary and I remember praying that God would send a dream to my mum, rather than to my boyfriend, to explain what was going on.

But I guess, in all seriousness, this was the start of my giving up on my calling, setting aside the foolish things of my childhood and seeking other paths in life.  I got a place at Oxford, a job in the City and good things followed – a nice home, a family and a rewarding career where I was valued and treated as an equal alongside my mostly male colleagues.

I started going back to church in my mid thirties to get the children into the local church primary school and I thought I could then drift away again after this mission had been accomplished.  But God took the opportunity to renew my faith and my calling and I discovered that, thanks to the persistence and sacrifice of brave women and men like those at MOW (The Movement for the Ordination of Women), women could become priests and vicars.

That was, therefore, the beginning of a journey that finds me now happily serving as the vicar of a small parish in West London, doing all the things that Father Stephen had done many years ago.

End of happy story, yes?  But also no.

Because, although I am a vicar in the Church of England, I am not a vicar on the same terms as I would be if I were a man.  Although almost every Anglican in the land has wanted ministry in the Church to be equally open to men and women from the 1970s onwards, there have been certain small powerful groups within the Church that have resisted this vigorously and viciously.  This meant that legal provisions were made in the 1990s to allow parishes, if they wanted, to say no to women priests.  And then later, in 2014, when the barriers were removed that had prevented women priests from becoming bishops, new legislation enabled ‘flying bishops’ to be appointed so that parishes, if they wanted, could say no to women bishops.

So I serve in a church where parishes can still advertise for a new vicar and ask for men only to apply, where bishops who are women are required to delegate their authority of oversight to male bishops for some of their parishes, where some of my colleagues espouse a theology that says God created men to lead and women to be led, and where some of my colleagues believe I am not actually a priest (that my ordination was invalid.)  And the official position of the Church is that we want these people, with the theologies that underpin their positions, to flourish.

But hang on a second, I hear you say.  Isn’t this kind of discrimination illegal in the UK today under The Equality Act 2010?  And the answer is that yes it would be – except the Church of England has exemptions under that legislation which allow it to discriminate.

OK, you might say.  But people like bishops who hold public office can’t be exempted under the Act.  And that’s true, which means that women bishops should operate on precisely the same terms as men bishops.  But in 2014 the Church got an amendment to the legislation saying that, for the purposes of the Act, bishops do not hold ‘public office.’  Which is somewhat extraordinary, since twenty six of them sit in the House of Lords.

So what on earth is going on?  How can we be in 2022 and the national Church is still discriminating against women, who represent about two thirds of their congregations and half the population?

The arguments boil down to largely two things: one, those who say we can’t have women priests because the Roman Catholic Church doesn’t allow them; two, those who say God created men, and only men, to be in charge and the Bible attests to this.

I can’t get into the response to all this in this short post.  Suffice it to say that the arguments and theology have been hotly contested over the years and millions of words have been written.  But the Church’s legislative council, General Synod, came to the conclusion that there is no theological basis for women to be prohibited from being priests or bishops.  Which should have been an end to the matter, as the purpose of such councils is to resolve theological disputes and make decisions to bring unity and then allow the Church to move forward.  When the apostles Paul and Peter in the early Church debated whether Gentile Christians needed to be circumcised or not, they came to a conclusion and special provisions were not made for dissenters.  Nonetheless, two thousand years later, special provisions were made for those who continue to say no to women priests and bishops.  And, because of these provisions, the old discredited arguments and theologies not only continue, but are often seen on a par with the arguments and theology underpinning the validity of women’s ministry.

My personal belief is that we are a separate Church from the Roman Catholic Church and can make our own decisions on women’s ministry, as we have on many other areas of doctrine such as allowing priests to be married.  And I believe that God created humankind in his image, in his image he created us, male and female – as we read in the first chapter of Genesis.  So that we do not reflect that image of God when men and women are not equal in the Church.

The women and men behind the Movement for the Ordination of Women did great work back in the 1990s and earlier, and we have so much to thank them for.  But the work for equality for women in the Church is not done.  This is why I have accepted the role of Chair at WATCH (Women and the Church), which campaigned for women bishops and now seeks equality for all in our national Church.  I hope and pray that, in my lifetime, I will not only see the Church give up its exemptions from UK equalities legislation but also come to truly value women, both ordained and lay, and lament how it has treated us in the past.

Please join WATCH here to help.

 

Comments

5 responses to “Thirty Years On”

  1. Tony Wesley avatar
    Tony Wesley

    I’ve often reflected on the British “solution” for the “problem” of women priest and bishops. My sense is that the same approach will probably be worked out for those vexing people seeking celebrations of their marriage. (Since tone doesn’t come across, this is said with sarcasm. 65 year old queer here married in every sense to my same sex spouse for 36 years). In any case, whereas this “solution” is certainly “nice” and may permit people to sit at the same table sipping tea together, does it reflect the justice that is demanded of us as we gather around the Lord’s table. Nice does not equal kind. Nice is not a theological virtue. Kindness is such a virtue which demands sacrifice and humility.. Thank you for your powerfully and clearly written words.

    1. martineoborne avatar

      I fear if we go down that route we are going to have a very complex fragmentation within the Church. Women need to speak up and explain why mutual flourishing isn’t working so that the Church doesn’t try to do this on other issues.

  2. Sandra avatar
    Sandra

    Your article is written from the heart. Thank you.

    We met a couple of years ago at West Kensington. One of the PCC had the good sense to ask for a woman to be present at that meeting. Reading your article I am happy it was you who was sent to us. It was not easy to speak up especially as I was just learning about some factions of the church not agreeing to women in leadership and wondered if I dare speak up on this issue.

    Some emails were sent to the PCC saying there will never be a woman leading this church. A few men still get up and leave now if there is a female preaching.

    We can at church now advertise that the post of vicar is open to both sexes. But what a journey it was to get to this point – two years later. The church Society are the patrons and I hear they come into play when a vicar is needed. Let’s see what happens when the time comes to advertise the post. How does a church swop it’s patrons?

    I think churches should write on their notice boards that the church is a complementarian conservative evangelical church and give a description of what that means in my language, e.g this church does not support women in leadership. When I mention this title people ask me what it means and cannot believe that the church is so archaic. If I read that description on the notice board I would not go in. Now that I have learned and if I go to a new church, I will ask questions because I have learned.

  3. Andrew Godsall avatar
    Andrew Godsall

    I remember standing in Dean’s Yard on that day 30 years ago when synod voted. I’d spent several years working for an organisation that simply did not allow the kind of discrimination that passed for normal in the C of E. On my first day at the BBC in October 1977 I was told that there were three things it was worth me noting about the corporation that would help me in the years to come. One was that everyone referred to everyone else by their Christian name. It didn’t matter where in the organisational hierarchy you were. Secondly, everyone ate in the same canteen. There was no high table. Thirdly, women and men were equal and were to be treated equally in every respect. In 1988 when I was ordained, firstly I was referred to as Mr Godsall. Secondly I noted that bishops ate in London clubs and the House of Lords. Thirdly it was abundantly clear that women were treated unequally in every respect. For many years I wondered what on earth I had done joining such an organisation. That day in November 1992 marked one change that we need to remember. And thank the MOW that it happened.

  4. John Davies avatar
    John Davies

    I still find all this legalised discrimination difficult to accept. At one time I belonged to a Baptist church, which had a big battle when the second minister’s wife wanted ordination – a lot of our people were influenced by David Pawson and the Restoration movement. And Mr Pawson was seen as a prophet, the next thing down from God, and what he said was so. It’s the only time I’ve ever heard a public church figure denounced as unacceptable from the pulpit. (She got what she wanted, but, oh, dear, the subsequent disaster….)

    Me, well apart from reading Elaine Storkey and Men, Women and God, I’d always had lady managers at work. What’s the problem in church? Oh, yes, the Bible says….. So I had one set of principles in my place of work, another on a Sunday. I prefer consistency.

    My Christian background is low evangelical. That side of me agrees with Martine – since when have we, as Protestants, had to take any notice of what Rome thinks? But, unfortunately we’re a very mixed body when it comes to church cultures, and always have been. A broad church has strengths, but it also has weaknesses, and fear of rocking the collective boat is one of them. Trying to be all things to all men is Biblical, but sadly not always possible.

    There’s a few other areas of issue as well; church bureaucracy for one has multiplied since the days of ‘every member ministry’, stifling the freedoms the Holy Spirit brought. The idea of a ‘reserved role’ for one person, without which you cannot celebrate Communion is another. No wonder the ‘new churches’ flourished so plentifully. A good many years ago someone at Spring Harvest, or the Dales, (I forget which) prophesied that God would judge the established denominations for their apostacy and bring them down – that it was good to see God shaking the dead wood out of the tree. Somewhat arrogant, I agree, but I wonder if we could see the fulfillment of that message by next Easter?

Any thoughts?