The Bishops must be Bolder and Braver on Gaza

by Dr Jonathan Chaplin, a Fellow of Wesley House, Cambridge and a lay member of Ely Diocesan Synod*

Two weeks ago, Archbishop Welby reversed his earlier refusal to meet prominent Palestinian Christian leader, Revd Dr Munther Isaac, on account of the fact that Isaac had shared a platform with Jeremy Corbyn at a pro-Palestinian rally in London. For the first time, he also used the word ‘condemn’ of the Israeli onslaught on Gaza. These are important steps in a much-needed rebalancing of the Church of England’s official stances on the Gazan catastrophe.

But there is more to do. Since October, the House of Bishops has issued three statements on the war, most recently in February. Coming from the appointed teachers of the established Church, they deserve a respect which must include critical scrutiny. Many elements of these statements are commendable, but they fall short on two fundamental counts.

First, while the bishops eventually made clear their ‘moral’ disapproval of the Israeli military campaign, they fail explicitly to name Israeli actions as violations of international humanitarian law and war crimes.

At this point there can be no doubt on the matter. As early as late October, a public letter from British lawyers to the UK government – now signed by 1100 – made clear that, even then, there was ample evidence of multiple specific violations of many international laws by the Israeli state. Months later, the extent and severity of these violations has expanded enormously. In January, the International Court of Justice delivered the extraordinary ruling that Israeli actions were ‘plausibly genocidal’, ordering Israel urgently to take all measures to prevent that outcome (which it has ignored).

The horrifying scale of deaths and injuries has been amply reported, resulting from recklessly disproportionate and indiscriminate Israeli bombardments. Almost all Gazan hospitals are destroyed or dysfunctional. 80% of the population has been displaced and are barely surviving in catastrophically inhumane conditions while still under military assault. Well over 50% of buildings in Gaza have been damaged or flattened, meaning most Gazans will have nowhere to return when the fighting stops. 90% of educational institutions, numerous churches and mosques and irreplaceable cultural sites have been damaged or destroyed, and much agricultural land has been rendered useless. Many Gazans now face starvation due to continuing drastic Israeli restrictions on the supply of humanitarian aid – another war crime – and official bodies have reported that children are already dying as a result.

None of this can remotely be justified under Israel’s ‘right to defend itself’, a phrase repeatedly but uncritically invoked by the bishops. As Francesca Albanese, UN special rapporteur for the West Bank and Gaza, observes, a state cannot invoke this right against a territory that it is belligerently occupying. Israel is not bound by some iron necessity to inflict this level of devastating collective punishment on defenceless Gazans. International law demands that Israel find other ways to protect its citizens against Hamas and retrieve its hostages.

It is not enough for the bishops merely to express ‘moral’ disapproval of such criminal acts, since this is easily dismissed as a subjective judgment that can be legitimately contested. If what is happening in Gaza is to be truthfully described, these acts must be named as publicly verifiable and culpable breaches of international law.

Second, the bishops’ statements fail to convey anything like an adequate recognition of the larger historical and political context of sustained Israeli oppression of Palestinians, since at least the 1967 illegal occupation. That complex history is, of course, read through radically different lenses. But there is ample verifiable evidence to support the bishops’ issuing a much fuller acknowledgement of the scale, intensity and recent harsh escalation of Israeli state oppression of Palestinians, which the Israeli human rights organisation B’Tselem in 2021 named as amounting to ‘apartheid’.

The House of Bishops urgently needs to speak more bravely into a calamity in which Britain is itself deeply implicated historically. It will thereby send a much more credible message of Christian solidarity to the people of Gaza who have felt abandoned by many western churches.

*an edited version of a speech in support of Dr Chaplin’s private member’s motion at Ely Diocesan Synod on 9 March 2024, seconded by the Revd James Shakespeare (Rural Dean, Cambridge South). The motion, which was carried narrowly, calls on the House of Bishops to issue a much stronger statement on Gaza that they have so far.

Comments

7 responses to “The Bishops must be Bolder and Braver on Gaza”

  1. David avatar
    David

    Any support for palestinian terrorists by the CoE is tantamount to condoning their action in the October massacre. The occupants of Gaza have consistently and overwhelmingly approved of the actions of hamas in this attack and deserve all that has happened to them.

    1. the Rev Brynn Craffey avatar
      the Rev Brynn Craffey

      What a very un-Christlike response.

    2. Colin Pengelly avatar
      Colin Pengelly

      Sadly I have to agree. I cannot foresee a culture where the extent of the anger of Hamas grew without the conscious consent of the population around them. Maybe they were scared to resist or maybe they were giving their tacit consent, but that is where my concern over the criticism of the IDF becomes understandable.

      1. Brynn Craffey avatar
        Brynn Craffey

        Setting aside your un-Christlike defense of revenge, pray tell, exactly what consent did the more than 10,000 (and counting) Palestinian children murdered since Oct 7th give?

  2. Jonathan Jamal avatar
    Jonathan Jamal

    Thes Church of Englence and Bishops need to be mindful that in the Diocese in Jerusalem, many Palestinian Anglican Christians, will feel a sense of being let down by the Mother Church of Anglicanism in the failure of their Bishops to be unequivocal in their condemnation of the actions of the Sate of Israel, which amount to War Crimes, Genocide as well as other breaches of International Law. The Church of England Bishops need to be aware of that Church Leaders in the Middle East particularly the Church Leaders in Jerusalem work together Ecumenically and make their Statements ecumenically and it is not only their fellow Anglicans they let down by their failure to be unequivocal in their public pronouncements but also Sister and Brother Christians of other Churches. Many Palestinian Christians in recent years have left the Holy Land to go western Nations as they no longer feel they can practice their faith in the Motherland of that faith. It would be a great tragedy if there was no longer a Christian presence in the Holy Land. The Church of England needs to wake up to the reality of the Ideological and Religious Agenda of Jewish Zionists, who want an Israeli State Ethenically cleansed of Both Muslims and Christians and have a Jew only State, with both Churches and Mosques being destroyed and all the Christian Holy Places razed to the Ground, as Jewish Zionists believe that unless the Land is ethnically and Religiously cleansed the Messiah will not come. Just as So Called Christian Zionists believe, there is a need for Nuclear War in the Holy Land to hurry up the Return of Christ. The Politcal and Religious Implications of this kind of Religious Fanaticism and Religious Mania are very serious and have very serious political implications in the Holy Land. The Church of England Bishops really need to wake up to this. Jonathan

  3. Wm Arthurs avatar
    Wm Arthurs

    As the late C H Sisson said “We all live on a diet of inaccurate news, supplemented by odds and ends from our own sources. To jump from that to an assumption of authority to judge the actions of countries of which we know even less than we do of our own must be a gross presumption. And in our own country, our role is limited to a very little rational action, and almost unlimited expression of ill-informed opinion. For my part, I should be reassured by a Church which directed our attention to our neighbours, to the daily life we actually lead.”

    1. James avatar
      James

      So then your advice in, say, the 1930s would have been silence? If that is the case, it would have been all of a piece with most of the churches of that time, which remained largely mute and impassive in the face of what was fast becoming increasingly obvious to anyone who could read and think.

      Moreover, as you must surely know, the greatest enduring influence on Sisson was Péguy, and he was also influenced to a large degree by Maurras (the leading anti-Dreyfusard). Therefore, Sisson’s ideological lodestars were the two ‘integral nationalist’ talismen of the Vichy regime.

      What is happening in Gaza is one of the best documented outrages in recorded history. That little of what has been documented has made its way into the deeply compromised, complicit and biased ‘Western’ media is scarcely surprising, but a younger and wiser generation is getting a good deal of unexpurgated footage (much of it taken by the IDF itself) from sources like Tik-Tok, which is presumably why much of the US government wishes to ban it (in contravention of the First Amendment).

      If the Church has little or nothing to say about this, then what is it for exactly? That is, of course, a rhetorical question.

Any thoughts?